Full MANTA implementation work tracker¶
Development tracker #617, MANTA full implementation alongside libint: capability and claimable work tracker, covers the full approved design. MANTA stays an optional provider alongside libint. Provider selection, Coulomb algorithm and exchange approximation remain independent; BUPO supplies J, not K. The full goal remains unfinished.
The engine capability matrix, scientific contracts and implementation and acceptance plan retain their technical requirements. Issue numbers below refer to the development tracker. The issues contain starting files, a first bounded increment, dependencies, acceptance criteria and pickup instructions. Read their current notes before claiming work; this map does not reassign an active owner.
Release boundary and accepted starting point¶
The bounded 0.18 controls are qualified
at containing main bc67d176. Their
benchmark
records source/native identities, complete calculations, strict refusals,
independent comparisons, cost and exclusions. Reuse that evidence for unchanged
behavior. It does not establish whole-method automatic accuracy or production
speedup. Candidate acceptance remains #557; the wider work below does not
enlarge that release gate.
Existing molecular scalar/range/FT, direct/RI/BUPO consumers and finite-source periodic HF/KS implementations are the starting point, not work to recreate. An old stage label is not evidence that a whole row is either absent or accepted. Conditional matrix entries require an implemented same-source route or a documented mathematical obstruction and explicit refusal.
Implementation packages¶
Completed packages retain their source and acceptance links; read the current issue state before claiming work. Remaining packages stay independently claimable within their stated dependencies.
Issue |
Design stage |
Remaining deliverable |
|---|---|---|
#618 |
P0/P1 |
role-specific capability query, planner-derived admission for the kernel, one-electron and kernel-free producers, and the limit inventory (deep signed contractions, ghost center) are on main; remaining provider capability and libint coexistence coverage continues |
#619 |
P1c |
libint-backend range-separated exchange (exact J/K), the shared guesses, spin seeds, ECPs (energies and exact/RI geometries), post-SCF dispersion, RHF/UHF harmonic frequencies, same-source atomisation references, QTAIM topology, molecular smearing and DFT+U energies and gradients are on main; remaining molecular method (ROHF/ROKS) and response compositions continue |
#620 |
P2b |
add bounded large-metric RI and RI-BUPO solves |
#621 |
P2a/P2b |
implement certified incremental direct and RI-BUPO builds |
#622 |
P3b |
stored-graph pair-tree metric bounds accepted at |
#623 |
P1/P3b |
bound integral and stored-source construction arithmetic |
#624 |
P2/P3b |
paired/retained Coulomb, evaluated assembly, direct K, BvK correction and whole-mesh fitted K accepted through |
#625 |
P3b |
opt-in omitted-image overlap rank guard connects shared spectral bounds to fixed-source and support-selection admission; conditional metric assembly rank and finite inverse/projector response are implemented; full construction arithmetic and occupied-space stability remain |
#626 |
P3b |
signed range admission and grouped reference bounds accepted through |
#627 |
P3b |
fixed-density certificate composition with no double counting, outward scalar summation, fail-closed bound admission and source/family-qualified full-Coulomb replacement and disjoint fitted-K composition for HF and signed global/range KS, plus an uncoupled second-order relaxation delimiter, are on main ( |
#628 |
P3b |
extend direct periodic BUPO electrostatics to complete KS compositions |
#629 |
P3a |
qualify same-source BIPOLE primitive substitution |
#630 |
P3c |
derive and implement slab and wire source families |
#631 |
P4 |
complete union-and-weight and WSSC provider adapters |
#632 |
P4 |
complete neutral Bloch and real-Gamma MANTA source coverage |
#633 |
P4 |
complete finite-character chi MANTA source adapters |
#634 |
P4 |
resolve conditional semiempirical long-range reuse |
#635 |
P5 |
qualify source-specific integral and BUPO symmetry reduction |
#636 |
P6a |
complete selected KS and BUPO molecular derivatives |
#637 |
P6a |
complete periodic and CCM gradients and cell stress |
#638 |
P1b/P2/P3b/P6b |
matched direct J/K baseline and shell-quartet reuse measured (benchmark); kernel arithmetic, dispatch and BUPO crossover remain |
#639 |
P6b |
qualify optional GPU, distributed and mixed-precision execution |
Capability matrix coverage¶
Every row of the engine capability matrix maps to the issues below. A row can have several consumers or conditional source proofs; completing one consumer does not close the row. These are work assignments, not new claims of supported methods or accepted accuracy.
Kernel or consumer row |
Implementation and acceptance issues |
|---|---|
Molecular S/T/nuclear, cross-basis S and moments |
#618; method composition #619 |
Two-center metric and three-center coupling |
#618; bounded solves #620; arithmetic and rank #623-#625 |
Four-center Coulomb and direct J/K |
#618, #619; incremental builds #621 |
erf/erfc two-, three- and four-center kernels |
#618; periodic range accuracy #626; source adapters #629-#633 |
Molecular exact J and exact K |
#618, #619, #616 |
Molecular RI-J and RI-K |
#619, #620, #624; independent K admission |
Molecular BUPO-J and RI-BUPO-J |
#619-#621; measured crossover #638 |
Gamma and multi-k exact/RI J/K |
#576, #607; accuracy #623-#627 |
Periodic BUPO-J and RI-BUPO-J |
#622-#628; large metrics #620 and cost #638 |
Nuclear gradients and cell stress |
#636, #637; separate derivative capability admission |
Numerical source row |
Implementation and acceptance issues |
|---|---|
Molecule or isolated finite cluster |
#618-#621, #616 |
Three-dimensional Gamma |
#576, #607, #622-#628 |
Three-dimensional multi-k and shifted meshes |
#576, #607, #622-#628 |
One- and two-dimensional periodic |
#630 |
BIPOLE active physical or historical source |
#629; shared domain/state owners #531 and #606 |
CCM union-and-weight and WSSC four-center |
#631 |
Neutral CCM Bloch |
#632 |
Neutral CCM real-Gamma |
#632 and existing source integration #519 |
Finite-character chi four-center |
#633 |
Finite-character chi RI |
#633 |
Finite-character chi RIJCOSX |
#633; preserve the existing COSX K source |
Low-dimensional CCM |
#630-#633; each named source needs its own proof |
SECCM, MSINDO-CCM, PM6, OMx, DFTB and GFN2 |
#634; conditional long-range subterm reuse only |
Source-qualified symmetry is #635 with shared admission #577/#608. Molecular and periodic derivatives remain #636/#637; CPU dispatch and accelerators remain #638/#639. Correlation tiles and factors reuse #581. These obligations apply across the relevant rows and do not follow from a passing scalar-kernel or Fock-action test. Conditional cells require the named same-source implementation or a documented mathematical obstruction and explicit refusal.
Existing issues reused¶
Issue |
Responsibility |
|---|---|
#616 |
Molecular evaluated-state integration alongside the libint bridge |
#607 |
Periodic bounded native evaluated-state/solver adaptation |
#576 |
Complete multi-k HF/DFT/hybrid MANTA control and parity ledger |
#581 |
Molecular/periodic correlation tile and factor admission |
#519 |
Neutral real-Gamma RG-8 source and consumer integration |
#577 |
Cross-method symmetry and Fock parity |
#567 |
Existing citation-route defect |
#557 |
Bounded 0.18 candidate acceptance only |
#643 |
Explicit automatic reference/metric and component reservations qualified at |
Shared Fock construction and eigensolvers remain under #472; PBC/BIPOLE and CRYSTAL23 parity under #593; full-SCF cost acceptance under #574; DLPNO under #508. These issues are dependencies and consumers, not competing implementations. MANTA provider symmetry uses the shared algebra and admission authority; no transport test alone permits production reduction. Correlation needs qualified integral tiles/factors, not merely a J action. Library/dependency defects retain their existing tracker owners.
Production readiness ledger¶
Snapshot of 2026-10-24 at containing main 4736aceb, reconciling every
capability-matrix row with what is implemented, what carries recorded
numerical acceptance, what the manual supports within an explicit envelope
and what stays experimental. Closed-issue counts are not readiness; an E
or stage label in the matrix does not
qualify its row. Four states are used. Implemented: the path exists
behind its method guards and its focused tests pass; no independent
numerical acceptance is claimed. Validated: a complete affected-method
calculation was compared with an independent reference (ORCA/CRYSTAL, an
independent NumPy/SciPy or Gaussian/Boys/Fourier construction, or a known
limit) with recorded source/native identity, inputs, tolerances and measured
errors, within the limits those records state. Supported: validated,
documented with its envelope (methods, sources, bases, limits, cost), refused
outside it before expensive work, and no longer labelled experimental for
that envelope. Experimental: everything else, including validated
components whose whole-method accuracy, cost or failure behaviour is not
established. Today no row reaches Supported: every MANTA route keeps the
experimental label (manual,
engine guide,
release controls).
Baseline refreshed on 2026-10-24¶
The bounded 0.18 MANTA contribution (#557) is a PASS for candidate
5dfc97f0: build 24463 and candidate pipeline 14816 succeeded, the final
native receipt’s core SHA256 and its 17 dependency hashes match the verified
predecessor, and the receipt’s native tree equals the candidate tree (tracker
#557, 2026-10-24). The accepted four-profile evidence remains the local
calculation set vq9c085769c600 on its own local core: 8 converged
calculations, 10 strict physical refusals and 1 expected old-cap refusal,
reusing the original HF and continuous-grid PBE0 component and independent
references (benchmark).
The local scientific core and the Linux candidate core are distinct binaries;
neither is a deployed runtime, and no cross-platform numerical parity is
claimed. That acceptance covers the four frozen profiles only (shifted
two-point Be RHF/PBE0 and a compact Gamma He RHF with RI-J, exact
full-Coulomb K, fixed supports, unreduced meshes). On 2026-10-24 the
compact-tight profile re-ran bitwise unchanged on main d8f937fb after the
#638 kernel change (all 1e-8 targets met; exchange 8.9e-12 / 3.0e-10 Eh,
nuclear 1.9e-17 Eh, kinetic 3.9e-13 Eh; local core, not a candidate binary).
Kernel and consumer rows¶
Row |
State |
Evidence and envelope |
Open |
|---|---|---|---|
Molecular S/T/nuclear, cross-basis S, moments |
Implemented; Bloch S/T validated |
One-electron operations through l=6 and moments to order 6 behind |
#618 |
2c metric and 3c coupling |
Implemented |
|
#620 bounded solves; #623-#625 arithmetic and rank |
4c Coulomb and direct J/K |
Implemented; consistency-checked |
Direct digestion through l=6 matches the libint reference to 1e-10 Ha (water/cc-pVDZ) and to 3e-12 Ha on four small fixtures with identical shell schedules; 9.5x slower than libint after shell-quartet reuse (cost benchmark); screening none by design |
#638 kernel arithmetic and dispatch; #621 incremental builds |
erf/erfc 2c/3c/4c kernels |
Implemented; periodic component bounds validated but loose |
Kernels exist; the erfc quadrature target 2e-14 is not a rigorous bound; the libint backend refuses range-separated exchange. Periodic raw and pre-SCF signed range bounds accepted at |
#626 useful bounds; #629-#633 source adapters |
Molecular exact J and K |
Implemented; consistency-checked |
RHF/UHF/RKS/UKS gas phase through |
#619 remaining compositions; #616 evaluated-state bridge |
Molecular RI-J and RI-K |
Implemented; consistency-checked |
All eight J×K selections; RI HF Lagrangian gradients including fitted ECP results; RI-J −29 µHa and RI-J/K +21 µHa versus exact on water/cc-pVDZ (manual, unhashed) |
#619, #620, #624 |
Molecular BUPO-J and RI-BUPO-J |
Implemented; construction validated |
Exact terminal confirmation; J error 8.6e-14 and energy 1.3e-13 on the benchmark cases, but no far block passes strict admission on water or the dimers and optimized libint is faster than every MANTA path (BUPO benchmark); gradients and incremental builds gated |
#620, #621, #638 crossover |
Gamma and multi-k exact/RI J/K |
Implemented; component-validated on frozen profiles |
Neutral all-electron 3-D cells with explicit fixed supports, HCORE/AUTO guess, no DIIS; release-control profiles accepted (above); fitted-K radii ≤1.9e-15 Fock and ≤9.4e-14 Eh accepted at |
#576 complete parity; #607; #623-#627 |
Periodic BUPO-J and RI-BUPO-J |
Implemented (HF, exact reciprocal K); experimental RI multipoles |
Public RHF/UHF only; RI multipoles labelled experimental, qualified for RI-J with exact K or pure KS; BUPO J ≤2.0e-13 / energy ≤2.8e-14 on sources |
#622-#628, #620, #638 |
Nuclear gradients and cell stress |
Implemented (molecular HF exact/RI incl. ECP, DFT+U); absent periodic |
Molecular HF gradients validated against finite differences and the legacy gradient in tests, no hashed page; KS gradients, BUPO gradients, periodic gradients and stress refused |
#636, #637 |
Numerical-source rows¶
Source |
State |
Evidence and envelope |
Open |
|---|---|---|---|
Molecule / finite cluster |
Implemented |
Rows 1-7 above; no hashed acceptance, experimental label |
#616, #618-#621 |
3-D Gamma; 3-D multi-k and shifted meshes |
Component-validated on frozen profiles |
Release controls on |
#576, #607, #622-#628 |
1-D / 2-D periodic |
Not implemented |
Periodic route is 3-D only; dimensionalities refused; low-dimensional boundaries excluded from the release scope |
#630 |
BIPOLE active/historical source |
Not implemented |
No MANTA adapter; supports do not substitute BIPOLE AC/BD domains |
#629 (#531, #606 owners) |
CCM union-and-weight / WSSC |
Not implemented |
CCM MANTA routes unqualified |
#631 |
CCM neutral Bloch |
Not implemented |
Same |
#632 |
CCM real-Gamma |
Partial |
|
#632, #519 |
chi four_center / ri / rijcosx |
Not implemented |
No adapter documented |
#633 |
Low-dimensional CCM |
Not implemented |
#630-#633 |
|
SECCM / MSINDO-CCM / PM6 / OMx / DFTB / GFN2 |
Not implemented |
Conditional long-range reuse only |
#634 |
Cross-cutting¶
Symmetry: the finite-product algebra correction d5a519cb is an
experimental handoff, not producer qualification; the bounded release
controls do not depend on it (#635). Arithmetic: paired, evaluated-assembly
and fitted-K arithmetic are accepted through 9e3a8c9a; input/XC
construction and remaining non-paired arithmetic stay open (#623, #624).
Automatic accuracy: the three fixed-density certificates are separate
ledgers with different reference objects and must not be summed into a
relaxed-energy tolerance; no relaxation, overlap-rank or k-mesh contribution
exists (#625, #627). Cost: MANTA is slower than libint on every measured
path and no BUPO crossover is established (#638). GPU, distributed and
mixed precision: not started (#639).
What this means for a production verdict¶
Supported configurations: none without the experimental label. The narrowest candidate envelope is molecular RHF/UHF/RKS/UKS with exact or RI J and K on all-electron and ECP Hamiltonians, where results match the libint route to 1e-10 Ha and gradients match finite differences, but it lacks a hashed acceptance page, a matched ORCA comparison and acceptable cost. The periodic envelope is the four frozen profiles with fixed supports, which carry component certificates but no whole-method accuracy or bulk parity. Failure behaviour is explicit: unsupported compositions refuse by name before the basis is built, and unmet accuracy targets refuse before an archive is written. Remaining restrictions are the open rows above; the release-owned 0.18 scope stays unchanged by this ledger.
Parallel work and acceptance¶
Useful independent starts include the capability inventory, molecular job
composition, same-source BIPOLE adapter, conditional source proofs, derivative
primitives and benchmarks using already accepted APIs. Pair-tree stored-graph
metric bounds and the executed paired metric substep, including its exact-adjoint
J contribution, individual coupling actions and their paired J/energy
composition, including spin/k weighting, evaluated HF/KS assembly and
stored-input direct K, BvK correction, retained J and whole-mesh fitted K,
including signed evaluated Fock/energy composition, are accepted. Input/XC
construction, remaining
non-paired arithmetic and automatic
periodic accuracy remain the ongoing MANTA integration lane. The paired metric evidence is recorded in the
metric benchmark.
It does not close #624 or certify a complete arithmetic budget.
The exchange fitting benchmark
qualifies a separate full-Coulomb K component bound under #626. Its uniform
family bounds remain conservative. RI HF attachment is accepted at 2dfbd54d;
Global-hybrid KS attachment is accepted at 2dfb076d; raw erf/erfc component
bounds are accepted at f1698506; pre-SCF signed range composition is accepted
at 1c06da0c. Optional grouped reference bounds are accepted at da33a7dd.
XC, further reference tightening and useful source selection remain #626/#627.
Claim a bounded scope and intended files on the selected issue before editing
shared producers, and preserve existing owners, jobs and checkout changes.
Unassigned does not mean unowned. A dependency is the specific needed capability,
not a wait for every umbrella issue to close.
Use existing producer, Fock, numerical and symmetry APIs. Keep physical source, normalization, support, rank, zero-mode, charge and evaluated-state identities explicit. No silent dense fallback, source substitution, default change or removal of experimental labels follows from this tracker.
The implementing chat may implement, validate and accept its own increment.
There is no mandatory second reviewer or review-only hold. Land focused,
checked source promptly with ordinary CI skipped. Scientific acceptance and
issue closure require a complete affected-method calculation through vq,
matched to ORCA/CRYSTAL where suitable or to justified numerical/high-precision
references with limitations stated. Reuse valid evidence and a healthy runtime
containing the fix; record actual source/native identity, inputs, job/output
and comparison. Full CI is reserved for release candidates. Update the manual,
benchmark, citations and changelog when corresponding behavior ships.
Keep #617 open until every original matrix and stage obligation is accounted for by accepted work or an expressly conditional obstruction/refusal. Finishing #557 or one bounded work package does not complete the full goal.
The optional stored-operand fitting metric assembly guard advances #623/#625: it feeds actual tile-source entry enclosures into the existing strict spectral rank radius. Primitive/Fourier/phase/weight construction errors and inverse response remain separate open work. It does not retire the full source-error, automatic-accuracy or production-readiness obligations under #617. See scientific contract Section 5.55 and the metric spectrum benchmark.
Finite retained-projector and truncated-inverse response now consumes the conditional #623 assembly perturbation in the shared inverse certificate (#625, contract 5.56). It includes partial-rank rotation and moving relative cutoffs, and composes the stored-factor error without changing factors. Coupling/source construction and J/K/energy propagation remain open; this adds no whole-method accuracy or production verdict.
The optional #627 metric-action target can now include the #623/#625 conditional metric-assembly inverse response, propagated through the shared explicit or supported compressed coupling norms and fixed density support. Separate source/stored components avoid double counting; default physical sources and the global ledger are unchanged. Primitive/coupling construction, K propagation and total relaxed accuracy remain open (contract 5.57).
Conditional metric-source K response (#626) now has separate optional raw component targets across actual Gamma and ordered q owners, including physical range kernels (contract 5.58). It consumes the shared #623/#625 assembly/inverse proof and coupling norm producer. Existing fitting/signed aggregate/global ledgers stay distinct. Source operands, coupling, metric domain/screening response and relaxed accuracy remain unfinished under #617.
The #623 short-range metric Bloch phase is now enclosed from exact stored q/R vectors, including dot-product and sine/cosine evaluation, by the shared bounded Taylor/angle-doubling proof (contract 5.59). Existing optional metric assembly/rank and J/K source-response targets consume it. Physical sources and states remain unchanged. Primitive/Fourier/coupling-phase/weight and q/R construction, domains and whole-method accuracy remain unfinished.
The #623 reciprocal metric-weight construction proof (contract 5.60) now includes stored-vector squares, stored range parameters and exp evaluation, using the shared interval producer and existing physical kernel/zero modes. Metric rank/inverse and conditional J/K targets consume the expanded proof. The reciprocal prefactor, Fourier/coupling construction, domains, relaxation and useful automatic whole-method accuracy remain unfinished under #617.
The #623 reciprocal metric prefactor proof now includes pi and the exact stored-lattice determinant (contract 5.61), consumed by existing weight, rank/inverse and conditional J/K producers. Strict unresolved-volume refusal preserves the physical cell. Primitive/Fourier/coupling and vector generation, domains, relaxation and useful automatic whole-method accuracy remain open.
The #623 auxiliary Fourier construction enclosure (contract 5.62) now covers primitive Gaussian moments/decay, phase, signed contraction and arithmetic on stored representation coefficients across auxiliary l=0..7. The existing metric/rank/inverse/J/K chain consumes it; numerical panels remain unchanged. Basis/representation data generation, short-range/coupling construction, vector generation, domains and useful relaxed accuracy remain open.
The #623 two-center metric construction proof (contract 5.63) encloses radial seeds, primitive prefactors, center shifts, Hermite contraction and application of stored pure transforms through l=7. It feeds shared rank/inverse/J/raw-K bounds without changing numerical source or states. Basis/representation and vector-data generation, three-center/AO-pair coupling construction, domains, screening and relaxation remain unfinished; #623/#625/#617 stay experimental.
The #623 positive erfc radial proof (contract 5.64) tightens the short-range construction component without changing its reference or numerical producer. Bernstein positive-series panels and explicit tails avoid full/long-range subtraction; the ordinary Boys proof remains shared and unchanged. Existing metric/rank/inverse/J/raw-K consumers propagate the result. Useful automatic accuracy, coupling/data construction, domains and relaxation remain open.
The #623 representation construction proof (contract 5.65) removes the stored pure-matrix premise from auxiliary Fourier and two-center metric certificates. Exact rational-polynomial/sqrt bounds feed shared rank/inverse/J/raw-K without changing numerical transforms or states. Basis/vector data generation, coupling, domains/screening and relaxed response remain open; no symmetry permission is inferred. #623/#625/#617 remain experimental and unfinished.
The #623 orbital-pair Fourier construction component (contract 5.66) adds a shared certificate through orbital l=6 for Gaussian products, exact product centers, phase/moments, contractions and both pure transforms. It retains the numerical source and is currently a separate diagnostic. Full three-center coupling composition and propagation, stored input generation, domain/screening and relaxed response remain open. No existing metric/Fock/symmetry admission inherits this component automatically; #623/#617 remain experimental.
The #623 streamed three-center construction component (contract 5.67) covers the exact stored auxiliary/orbital Gaussian integral through l=7/6/6 for Coulomb/erf/erfc. Shared radial, elementary and representation proofs feed per-tile Hermite/Coulomb construction bounds without changing numerical tiles. Full periodic coupling composition and action propagation remain open, along with stored-input/image generation, domains/screening and relaxed accuracy. This component does not expand existing metric/Fock or symmetry admissions.
The #623 finite periodic coupling diagnostic (contract 5.68) composes shared three-center, Fourier, phase, lattice-weight and representation proofs over literal selected integer image sets, including translated centers and the finite-zero term. Separate tile/forward/adjoint certificates compare unchanged numerical routes directly with that unscreened finite reference. It closes the finite construction composition gap; propagation into J/K/RI-BUPO/SCF admission, input/domain completeness and relaxed accuracy remain open. Existing Fock/PBC/symmetry interfaces and metric budgets are preserved. #623/#617 remain experimental and unfinished; overlapping component budgets must not be added.
The retained-source discrepancy #687 is repaired by sharing the existing budgeted primitive selector between MANTA and libint, including dense and streamed paths. Screened source identities and split-call admission reflect the retained primitive set; unscreened sources stay unchanged (contract 5.69). Finite coupling/metric composition into J/K/RI-BUPO/SCF remains the next open accuracy increment; the primitive repair does not close #617 or that work.
The accepted #627 producer seam combines finite coupling construction, stored factor and metric-source response into a declared fixed-density J/energy certificate on the actual Gamma RI owner (contract 5.70). Explicit and compressed/global/pair-tree producers share the same reference and keep separate component radii. Complete-job automatic admission and reference- matched BUPO ledger composition, K response, metric translation generation and relaxed accuracy remain open; this standalone joint certificate does not close #627 or #617.
Local complete-method controls cover six explicit HF/KS profiles and three compressed/global/pair-tree profiles, with the existing independent references reused. The joint bounds still do not meet useful automatic accuracy targets. See the finite-source response evidence for component bounds, actual cost and the source/runtime qualification boundary.
The accepted #627 integration applies that joint certificate as a separate optional pre-SCF finite-source target in the existing complete-method selection loops (contract 5.71). Shared count planners reserve only requested construction proofs and retained trial receipts. This does not combine unlike full-Coulomb references, improve the bound magnitudes, or close the remaining source/domain, K and relaxed-state accuracy work.
The bounded admission passes nine unchanged complete-method profiles and selection/refusal controls. It does not establish useful automatic accuracy: a larger auxiliary control still has a very large finite metric-response bound. Preserve that failure of useful accuracy while reusing the accepted admission/state evidence; see the complete-method admission benchmark.
The accepted #627 residual metric and coupling responses (contracts 5.72 and 5.73) tighten the joint finite-source certificate without changing the physical source. The compact three-to-eight auxiliary RHF profile now passes finite J/energy targets 3e-8/1.5e-6 Eh and refuses an energy target of 1e-6 Eh within its existing search limits. The measured joint energy bound is 1.1078796248453086e-6 Eh; this is a fixed weighted-family finite fitted J response, not a total relaxed-energy tolerance. Compressed norm fallbacks and all other source/method matrix rows retain their existing qualification. See the finite coupling response evidence.
The next accuracy work must address the explicit remaining requirements: metric translation/input generation and reference-aligned composition with full-Coulomb fitting and executed arithmetic, followed by missing K/XC and relaxation contributions. Do not sum unlike ledgers or infer generic diffuse/ skew-cell, independent-spin, range, provider, derivative, GPU/distributed or symmetry readiness from this one bounded profile. Full #617 stays open.
Exact finite metric lattice images¶
The shared metric proof now encloses exact lattice-times-integer image centers and phases, matching the coupling convention for the selected integer set. Implementation140b95e0/reference repair506e14c7 is accepted through local vq 52f189aae41f: three unchanged complete states and three strict refusals. The larger eight-function control still admits finite J/E targets3e-8/1.5e-6 and refuses energy1e-6. Metric assembly/joint reference identities advance; source, rank, density and Fock identities remain unchanged. See the acceptance and exclusions.
This closes only selected metric image generation. Input/reciprocal generation, image-domain completeness, infinite tails, full-Coulomb fitting, K, executed Fock/energy arithmetic and nonlinear relaxation remain separate. No total relaxed-energy, bulk CRYSTAL parity or speedup claim follows. Reference-aligned whole-method composition and the rest of #617 remain open and experimental.
Evaluated finite Coulomb response¶
Source1dee3252 composes the immutable finite-source certificate with one retained or paired executed-arithmetic proof at the evaluated stored spin density and weights. Local vq922d68c30af0 passes four unchanged complete states and three strict refusals. The eight-function auxiliary evaluated Coulomb energy bound is1.1078799401486478e-6 Eh. Existing pre-SCF targets remain source-only; the evaluated receipt does not silently extend their semantics. See bounds, costs and independent-reference limits.
This closes the raw J/Coulomb response arithmetic composition for the admitted finite reference. Restricted embedding, final assembly, physical/reference completion and nonlinear relaxation remain separate. The unlike full-Coulomb ledger is unchanged. Full#617 and useful automatic whole-method accuracy stay open and experimental; no total relaxed-energy, parity or speedup claim.
Euclidean finite-source metric envelopes¶
The shared owner-sealed column proof now also encloses Euclidean norms using scaled outward sums of squares (contract 5.78). Residual, inverse action and complex transpose/adjoint projection bounds retain the old envelopes as fallbacks. This reduces auxiliary-dimension loss without changing the numerical source, retained rank, fixed density family or shared Fock/PBC/ symmetry semantics. The existing L1 coupling norm keeps its interpretation. See the bounded acceptance.
The full #625/#627/#617 scope remains open. Source-only targets do not certify nonlinear SCF relaxation, and the finite-source reference is not the infinite full-Coulomb reference. Input, domain, exchange, assembly and relaxation gaps remain explicit; this increment grants no new symmetry or performance claim.
Finite Coulomb through evaluated assembly¶
The shared assembly audit now consumes the immutable finite Coulomb response and binds it to actual density/weights, held inputs and evaluated witnesses (contract 5.79). It adds assembly-only arithmetic once, closing final Fock and energy assembly for the exact finite Coulomb reference with other supplied components held fixed. Existing combined arithmetic and full-Coulomb ledgers remain separate. See the assembly acceptance.
This does not certify construction or response of the held non-Coulomb components, ideal restricted embedding, physical-domain completion or SCF relaxation. Pre-SCF source-only targets and Fock/PBC/symmetry ownership are unchanged. The full #624/#627/#617 scope remains experimental and open.